Prof. Dr. Manuela Boatcฤ, our head of school, about the essay by our student Gian Mante from the Batch 2026:
โPossibly the best student answer out of a range of very good and original ones this year. You can get the perfect grade for this question without memorizing anything, looking anything up – though it’s an open-book exam – or using AI. Instead, as the exam sheet stated, you can ‘Use this opportunity to show what you took from this class, instead of looking for standard answers elsewhere’.”
Using the example of a region of your choice, argue for the importance of a global and historical perspective for analysing it.
โHave you ever seen a cocoa tree?โ is a question my Ghanaian roommate posed when we had a discussion about Swiss chocolate, and he told me that most of Switzerlandโs cocoa supply used for the production of chocolate is imported from Ghana. My answer was no, to which he replied that he has met cocoa farmers who have never seen a bar of chocolate. It was only after this discussion that I questioned the โSwissnessโ of chocolate produced in Switzerland, a product that I have enjoyed my entire life.
To understand the connection between the role of Ghana as one of the worldโs leading exporters of raw cocoa beans and the branding of โSwiss chocolateโ as a sign of a quality product, it is necessary to put both actors in a broader global and historical framework. I argue that without a global and historical lens, it is not possible to understand why chocolate can not only be sold as a Swiss product but is a cornerstone of the countryโs (inter)national image and identity, when its main ingredient relies on a climate that is found nowhere in Europe. Seen through a global and historical perspective, it becomes clear that Swiss chocolate is a product of a centuries-long relationship between Europe and Africa.
Cocoa is not native to Ghana. The Plant was shipped from South America and was introduced to the Gold Coast, a British Colony located where Ghana is today in the 1830โs. Swiss Missionaries were part of the cash-crop cultivation of Cocoa soon after. The production proved extremely lucrative and allowed the chocolate production industry to grow in Europe.[Schweizerisches Nationalmuseum: Cocoa in Ghana: How it all began. https://blog.nationalmuseum.ch/en/2024/11/cocoa-in-ghana-how-it-all-began]
Steven Feiermans African Histories and the Dissolution of World History (1993) critiques predominant conceptions of world history such as McNeillโs Rise of the West or Braudelโs Civilisation Maternelle, in which they understand Africa as a peripheral, ahistoric actor that is mostly defined through its interactions with the West (Feierman 1993: 169-175). While Braudel draws on Wallersteinโs concept of core and periphery, he still โcharacterizes โBlack Africaโ as passive and inertโ (1993:174). He also shows how fixed Ideas of โcivilisationโ with European practices as its basis, cannot be applied to Africa. African agricultural practices, political hierarchies and such are seen through the lens of European historians, are misunderstood and therefore dismissed as undeveloped (1993: 177).
In Walter Rodneyโs Text How Europe underdeveloped Africa, the inherent European understanding of Africa as inferior to Europe is applied to global economy. One way he understands the term โunderdevelopmentโ is through a relationship of exploitation, โnamely, the exploitation of one country by anotherโ (Rodney 1973: 24). All underdeveloped countries, he writes, have been and are still exploited by others. After exploitation starts in a particular country, surplus of labour and resources is exported to another country, whereby the exploited is left without it (1973: 25). One aspect through which many African countries are exploited is through trade. The terms of trade are set by one country, usually the wealthier one, in a way that they can extract the most profit from the trade. If agricultural goods are shipped from parts of Africa to parts of Europe, and finished products are exported from Europe, for example, then the price of goods and the necessary freight rates are set by the wealthier country (1973: 38). Even more integral to underdevelopment than trade is the ownership of the means of production. The most direct form of exploitation of Africa by Europe if citizens of a European country own, for example, the land on which mines are located in Africa. While the amount of Europe-owned land in Africa has shrunk significantly since colonial rule, foreign ownership is still present. Through that, portions of wealth flow from Africa directly to Europe. These two mechanisms, trade and foreign ownership, create a structural dependence (1973: 42).
Applied to the relationship between Switzerland and Ghana, it is clear to see who the exploiter is and who is the exploited. Ghana exports enormous amounts of raw cocoa to Switzerland, where the final product, chocolate, is manufactured and then exported at much higher prices. The trade relations between the two countries function exactly according to the pattern Rodney describes. While Ghana produces a big share of the worldโs cocoa beans, only a small portion of the value that is generated by chocolate ends up in Ghana.
Even though Switzerland never officially had any colonies, its chocolate industry greatly benefited from trade systems that had been established by other European countries. Switzerland, I argue, still fits into the colonial framework because it shows the unequal economic relationship that has been made possible through colonial rule and reflects processes that ended in the underdevelopment of Ghana.