Vaccination skepticism and esoteric attitudes are linked
Freiburg political scientists prove that positive attitudes towards esotericism and alternative medicine influence Covid-19 vaccination rates and the reasons for vaccination
Covid-19 vaccination syringes. Photo: Jürgen Gocke / University of Freiburg
Esoteric attitudes – especially with regard to complementary and alternative medicine – have an influence on the willingness to be vaccinated. Dr. Sebastian Jäckle and Dr. James K. Timmis, both from the Department of Political Science at the University of Freiburg, have demonstrated this in a new study. The researchers show that respondents who view conventional medicine positively have on average one more vaccination dose against coronavirus than respondents who view it negatively. Respondents who are in favor of Waldorf education and homeopathy are significantly less likely to be vaccinated (a second time). “People with a positive view of homeopathy received an average of 0.4 fewer coronavirus vaccine doses than those who do not trust homeopathy,” explains Jäckle. “With a maximum of four vaccine doses possible up to the time of the survey, these are very substantial effects.” The study, in which more than 7,000 people across Germany took part in 2022, was published in August in the journal npj Vaccines, which is part of the Nature portfolio.
Varying motivations for vaccinations
The study also sheds light on the different motivations of respondents to get vaccinated against coronavirus: Those who were in favour of conventional medicine stated that they followed medical advice and the recommendation of the Standing Committee on Vaccination (STIKO) or focused on protecting others. Those in favour of Waldorf education and homeopathy were motivated, among other things, by being able to participate in public life – such as going to restaurants – without any problems when vaccinated.
Furthermore, the analysed data indicate that positive attitudes towards esotericism, complementary and alternative medicine not only lead to a lower number of coronavirus vaccination doses, but also negatively influence the view of childhood vaccinations in a very similar way. This finding differs from study results from the USA, which showed that attitudes towards coronavirus vaccination and paediatric vaccination differ. ‘This knowledge can help to better measure the willingness of the population to be vaccinated and to plan vaccination campaigns in a more targeted manner,’ says Timmis.
Further information
- Original publication: Jäckle, S., Timmis, J. K. Esoteric beliefs and CAM impact SARSCoV-2 immunization drivers, uptake and pediatric immunization views in Germany. npj Vaccines 9, 137 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41541-024-00928-7
- Dr. Sebastian Jäckle is a member of the Department of Political Science at the Chair of Comparative Government at the University of Freiburg, where he also works as an assistant professor.
- Dr. James K. Timmis is also a member of the Department of Political Science at the Chair of Comparative Government at the University of Freiburg and supervises Master’s research projects in the field of Health Innovation at the Vrijen Universiteit Amsterdam.